Kunwer Sachdev

India’s Innovation Paradox: When Will Failure Be Our Launchpad, Not Our Wrong doing?

AI image of Space X

India’s Innovation Paradox: When Will Failure Be Our Launchpad, Not Our Wrong doing?

Kunwwer Sachdev

Kunwwer Sachdev 

 
🔌 Inverter Man of India | Founder – Su-Kam & Su-vastika ⚡ Visionary Entrepreneur | Patent Holder | Tech Mentor I Member GMDA 🌍 Building India’s energy future, one breakthrough at a time.
 
 

The crackle and roar of a static fire test gone awry at SpaceX’s Starbase in Boca Chica, Texas – Ship 36, another data point, another fiery lesson. For Elon Musk and his audacious team, it’s a necessary, albeit costly, part of the process. They’ll dust themselves off, analyze the telemetry, and build the next iteration stronger, smarter. The world watches, sometimes with a grimace, but largely with an understanding that grand ambitions come with grand challenges. It’s not the USA, where even the most audacious entrepreneurs like Musk have faced their share of “mistakes” – from production hell at Tesla to rocket explosions at SpaceX – but the public discourse largely remains focused on the relentless march of progress, treating setbacks as part of the journey.

But my mind, rooted here in the buzzing, striving, yet often unforgiving landscape of Indian entrepreneurship, immediately conjures a chilling parallel. What if that explosion, that plume of smoke and scattered debris, happened not in Boca Chica, but during a crucial beta test of a groundbreaking hardware startup in Gurugram, or a complex AI solution being rolled out in Bengaluru?

The thought sends a cold shiver down my spine, a familiar tremor of fear that many of us, as Indian entrepreneurs, live with daily. The headlines would scream. The prime-time debates would ignite, fueled by outrage and finger-pointing. “Waste of taxpayer money!” “Incompetence!” “CBI inquiry needed! ED raids!” Demands for accountability would overshadow any nuanced discussion of learning, iteration, or the inherent risks of pushing boundaries.

We, the entrepreneurs of India, fight a unique battle. We’re not just building businesses; we’re often fighting a societal narrative that equates failure with disgrace. From our schooling, where a single low mark can define a student’s future, to family expectations where a stable job trumps a risky venture, the message is subtly, yet powerfully, ingrained: do not fail.

Article content
AI generated image for EV truck make in India getting burnt

This cultural aversion to failure is a heavy invisible weight. It stifles innovation, discourages bold risks, and often drives brilliant minds towards safer, more conventional paths. How can we truly aspire to be a global innovation hub, a leader in AI, space tech, or sustainable energy, if every stumble is met with public shaming and the potential death knell of a dream?

Yet, amidst this challenging landscape, there are stories of remarkable resilience, quiet triumphs born from the ashes of public and private setbacks. These are the stories that remind us that the spirit of learning from failure does exist in India, often against tremendous odds.

Think of Educomp Solutions. Founded by Shantanu Prakash, Educomp was a pioneer in India’s education technology space, aiming to revolutionize learning with digital classrooms and smart content. For a period, it was a darling of the stock market, poised to transform the way millions of Indian children learned. However, Educomp’s model, heavily reliant on long-term credit arrangements with schools and an aggressive expansion strategy, eventually buckled under financial strain. The company went through a highly publicized corporate debt restructuring process and faced significant challenges. While allegations of financial irregularities later emerged against the promoters, a common lament in India, the public discourse often focused on the financial collapse, overshadowing the groundbreaking vision that attempted to bridge the digital divide in Indian education. The experiences of Educomp highlight critical lessons about business models, financial sustainability in a nascent market, and the perils of rapid scaling – lessons that could greatly benefit the current ed-tech boom, if we analyze them openly, separating alleged wrongdoings from the core business journey.

Another powerful example is Rolta India. For decades, under the leadership of Kamal Singh, Rolta was a significant player in GIS, engineering, and IT solutions, even serving defense sectors. It created advanced geospatial technologies and built a reputation for its capabilities. However, like many ambitious ventures, Rolta faced significant financial distress, accumulated massive debt, and eventually entered insolvency proceedings. While serious allegations of siphoning funds and financial misconduct later surfaced against its promoters, the fact remains that for years, Rolta represented a substantial Indian effort in complex technology domains. The discourse often collapses into a singular narrative of fraud, ignoring the innovation, the jobs created, and the technological capabilities developed. We must learn to differentiate between alleged malfeasance and the inherent risks and complexities of building and scaling large enterprises in a challenging environment.

These aren’t simple stories. They are raw, gritty narratives of individuals who faced the very real “gut punch” of failure, not just financially, but often socially and reputationally. They highlight that the capacity to learn and adapt is profoundly present within Indian entrepreneurial DNA, even when systemic and societal pressures are stacked against it.

Article content

The Starship incident serves as a powerful mirror. It forces us to ask: When will we, as a nation, evolve to a point where a rocket test anomaly, or a startup’s failed product launch, is seen not as a national embarrassment or a reason for a CBI inquiry or ED raids, but as a critical, albeit expensive, data point? When will our media focus on the lessons learned, the technological advancements gained, rather than just the immediate outcome? When will investors be willing to back founders not just for their successes, but for their ability to learn and pivot from their inevitable missteps, recognizing that even global icons like Elon Musk have navigated through considerable turbulence?

For India to truly harness its immense talent and innovation potential, we must collectively foster an environment where “failure is okay.” An environment where courage to experiment outweighs the fear of judgment. Only then can our entrepreneurs truly unleash their full potential, and only then will India’s innovations truly soar, not just occasionally, but consistently, towards a brighter, bolder future.

#IndianStartups #EntrepreneurshipIndia #Resilience #Innovation #Educomp #RoltaIndia #MakeInIndia #SpaceForFailure #StartupCulture

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top